• Menu
  • Skip to right header navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Before Header

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Phone
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

The Adoption Law Firm

  • About Us
    • About Us
    • Resources
  • Domestic
    • Overview
    • Foster-Care Adoption
    • Birth-Mother Adoption
    • Private Adoption
    • Stepparent/Grandparent Adoption
    • Embryo Adoption
  • International
    • Overview
    • Hague Country Adoption
    • Non-Hague Country Adoption
  • Blog
  • Podcast
  • Contact
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • Resources
  • Domestic
    • Overview
    • Foster-Care Adoption
    • Birth-Mother Adoption
    • Private Adoption
    • Stepparent/Grandparent Adoption
    • Embryo Adoption
  • International
    • Overview
    • Hague Country Adoption
    • Non-Hague Country Adoption
  • Blog
  • Podcast
  • Contact

Don’t Risk Having a Child Custody Case Overturned on Appeal

January 8, 2021 //  by Sam McLure

Parties in child custody cases must be certain that their juvenile court makes every necessary ruling, or risk having their judgment overturned on appeal.

E.H. v. Calhoun County Department of Human Resources,

Alabama Court of Civil Appeals, October 2, 2020

In custody cases where a child is alleged to be dependent, a juvenile court must make a finding of dependency when awarding custody. Section12-15-310(b), of the Alabama Code requires that this finding be made expressly. If the juvenile court judgment does not make an explicit finding of dependency, such a finding can be implied. But an appeals court will not always assume that it has been made. Parties wishing to uphold a custody determination should ask the juvenile court to amend its judgment to make the explicit finding, or risk losing their judgment on appeal. Conversely, parties seeking to challenge a juvenile court judgment should look for this as a ground for appeal.

In a recent case, E.H. v. Calhoun County Department of Human Resources, the Alabama Court of Civil Appeals reversed a juvenile court judgment that did not make the necessary explicit finding of dependency. In that case, the juvenile court had previously found the child dependent and DHR had removed the child from the mother’s home, placing the child with paternal grandparents. Later, DHR asked the court for both legal and physical custody of the child. The mother brought evidence showing she had made significant changes to her behavior and lifestyle. The juvenile court ruled in favor of DHR, but did not actually find that the child remained dependent.

On appeal, the Court of Civil Appeals reviewed the evidence in detail, and noted that the case was similar to a prior decision, H.C. v. S.L., 251 So. 3d 793, 794 (Ala. Civ. App. 2017). As in that case, there was evidence supporting a finding that the child was not dependent and the juvenile court did not make any determination about the child’s status at the time the judgment was entered. The Court of Civil Appeals thus reversed the juvenile court’s decision and remanded the case for it to properly determine whether the child was dependent at the time of final judgment.

The E.H. v. Calhoun County DHR case teaches us three important lessons: (1) when a juvenile court makes a custody ruling, it must make an express determination about the child’s dependency status at the time of the ruling; (2) parties who wish to uphold a juvenile court’s custody ruling where this step is left undone should ask the court to revise its judgment to include the required finding; (3) parties wishing to challenge a custody ruling should look for a missing dependency determination as a possible ground on which to have the ruling reversed.

-John Forrest

Previous Post: « How Much Does Adoption Cost | Podcast
Next Post: When Biological Parents Move to Another State under Custody Agreement »

Primary Sidebar

Quick Adoption Links

  • How to Write a Letter of Reference for an Adoption Home Study
  • Paying for Adoption
  • What is an Adoption Home Study?
  • What is the Monetary Cost of Adoption?
  • When Does an Internationally Adopted Child Become a US Citizen?

Recent Posts

  • Weak and Working: Reflections from a Foster Mother
  • Equipping Foster Parents for Gracious Advocacy Series, Part I
  • Introducing Surrogacy: The Legal Ins and Outs
  • Introducing Associate Attorney Morgan Broyles
  • Passion for Adoption Featured in The Alabama Lawyer

Receive Our Free
Email Newsletter

Signup Now!

“Sam McLure fights for adoptions with all his heart.  It’s not just his profession, but his passion.”
– Travis & Cheri Norwood

Footer

The Adoption Law Firm

The Adoption Law Firm is specifically focused on domestic and international adoptions.  We are located in Alabama and proudly serve the surrounding region.   Learn More . . .

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Phone

Testimonial

“We found The Adoption Law Firm to be knowledgeable, friendly, and helpful.  Sam helped us finalize our third adoption.  It was handled professionally and efficiently.  I love that there is a law firm that is committed not only professionally, but personally to adoption.” – Michael & Bonnie Eaves

Contact Us

P.O. Box 640667
Pike Road, AL 36064
334.546.2009

www.TheAdoptionFirm.com ·
No representation is made that the quality of legal services to be performed
is greater than the quality of legal services performed by other lawyers.